The Borges Real Estate Team
The Borges Real Estate Team
Steel casement windows on a Spanish Revival home in Pasadena
Buyer Resources - California

Should I Keep or Replace Steel Casement Windows in a Spanish Revival Home?

November 15, 20269 min readJustin Borges

I’m Justin Borges, and I help buyers and owners of character homes in Pasadena and the San Gabriel Valley. I would repair and keep steel casement windows when their frames are sound: they are part of a Spanish Revival home’s character, and they can be restored. I would consider replacement when rust or damage is beyond repair, or when the windows are failing in ways restoration cannot fix.

That decision deserves a closer look than opening a window once during a showing. In a Pasadena or San Gabriel Valley home, I want a buyer or owner to understand which windows need attention, what is causing the trouble and how a proposed repair or replacement will change the room. The answer can differ from window to window.

Ready to move forward? Let's talk.

Why do steel casements matter to the character of the house?

Steel casements can give a room a distinctive rhythm: slender framing divides the glass, and the operable sash sits within the opening. From outside, the pattern contributes to the elevation; from inside, it shapes the view and the way light falls across the room. Look at the window alongside the plaster, tile and arches rather than as an isolated fixture.

That does not mean accepting a window that will not close or leaks every time it rains. It means asking what can be repaired before changing the whole opening. Photograph the windows from inside and outside, including the hardware and the divisions in the glass. Those images give a specialist a useful starting point and help you compare a proposed replacement with what is there. Pasadena’s historic district guidelines identify street-facing windows as key character-defining elements and give secondary windows more flexibility.

For the larger design picture, see my guide to updating a Spanish Revival kitchen and bathrooms without losing character.

Have a question about the windows? Text me at (323) 673-2597.

What should I look for during an inspection?

Start with the condition of the metal, then look at how the window works and how it meets the surrounding wall. Surface rust and a frame that has lost material are different problems. Bubbling paint may hide corrosion, while staining around the opening can point you toward a leak that needs investigation.

The National Park Service guide to historic steel windows recommends examining corrosion, paint, bent or misaligned sections, glass, glazing compound and hardware. It distinguishes light surface corrosion from heavy corrosion that can cause structural damage. I would request a written window-by-window assessment of the depth and extent of corrosion rather than rely on appearance alone.

Ask the inspector to note which windows bind, whether handles and latches work, and whether the sash closes evenly against the frame. Look for cracked glass, loose or deteriorated glazing compound, gaps and signs of water at the sill or adjacent plaster. Do not force a stuck sash during a showing. Record each location.

Have questions about a home you are considering? Call me at (323) 673-2597.

Where is the water coming from?

A fresh coat of paint does not answer that question. The National Park Service guide to historic plaster notes that leaking gutters and downspouts can put water beside a building. Water may be reaching the window from the opening itself or from another detail above or beside it. Ask the inspector to look beyond the rusty spot at the sill, surrounding wall, nearby gutters and any visible staining. The National Park Service identifies moisture as the primary cause of corrosion in steel windows, so I would address its source first.

That matters when you receive a proposal. I would ask the contractor to identify what they believe is letting water in, what they can see now and what remains uncertain until the area is opened or tested. A window repair and a correction to the surrounding condition may need to be coordinated. Photograph the area before work and keep the written findings with the house records.

For related signs inside, read our guide to cracked plaster in Spanish Revival homes.

Want to talk through what you found? Text me at (323) 673-2597.

What can restoration involve?

Restoration is a description of work, not a single product. Depending on the condition, it may include removing rust and loose paint, treating and repainting the steel, replacing deteriorated glazing compound or cracked glass, and cleaning or lubricating hinges. The National Park Service notes that steel windows were historically coated with lead paint, so avoid abrasive or torch removal. For paid repair or replacement in a pre-1978 home, hire an EPA- or state-certified lead-safe firm when the RRP rule applies; window replacement never qualifies for the minor-repair exception, though the rule does not apply if testing establishes that the paint is free of lead-based paint. Missing or damaged hardware may need repair or replacement. Weatherstripping can be considered where air is passing around an operable sash.

The National Park Service steel window preservation guide distinguishes routine maintenance from more involved work. Ask a steel-window specialist for a line-item scope covering the moisture source and intended operation of each sash.

A useful written scope names the windows, describes the condition of each one, and separates confirmed work from conditions that may only become clear during repair. Include maintenance and signs of returning rust or water, then use the line-item scope to compare repair and replacement proposals.

To talk through your next steps, call me at (323) 673-2597.

Ready to move forward? Let's talk.

How should I compare repair with replacement?

QuestionRepair or restorationReplacement
What happens to the opening?Ask which existing frame, sash and hardware can remain.Ask how the new unit fits and what surrounding material will be disturbed.
How will it look?Review the proposed finish and any changes to glass or hardware.Compare frame profiles, pane divisions, color and sightlines from both sides.
How will it work?Ask what operation and sealing the work is intended to restore.Confirm the opening direction, latch and usable opening with the installer.
What needs checking?Confirm the scope and any local review with the appropriate authority.Ask the local building department about permits, applicable requirements and historic review.

Bring the same photos and measurements to both conversations. A replacement may change the visible width of the frame or the pattern of glass, even when it fits the same opening. Ask to see drawings or a sample that shows those details. The National Park Service recommends matching the material, configuration, color, operation, panes and proportions when replacement is necessary.

Pasadena’s historic district guidelines offer a practical benchmark: as a general rule, preserve a window when more than 50 percent of its components can be repaired, with selective component replacement where needed. When replacement is necessary, match the original appearance and retain the depth of the opening.

Considering your options? Text me at (323) 673-2597.

What should I ask about permits and historic review?

The Pasadena historic district design guidelines favor repairing historic windows where possible. For a Pasadena landmark district, street-visible exterior alterations need a Certificate of Appropriateness before a building permit is issued. In a landmark district, exterior alterations not visible from the street are exempt from historic review, although a building permit may still be needed. Individually designated landmarks are reviewed for exterior alterations whether or not they are visible, and a house under a Historic Property Contract needs a Certificate of Appropriateness for work on historic features. Check the city’s designated-properties database and district map, or contact Pasadena Current Planning. Before ordering windows or committing to a scope, give the local building department the property address and a description of the proposed work. Ask whether a permit, historic review or other approval applies, and what information the city needs. Do not assume that a neighbor’s project or a contractor’s experience in another city answers the question for your house.

Ask the installer to confirm applicable building and energy requirements, as well as any requirements affecting an opening used for emergency escape. Have the proposed window’s dimensions and operation available for that conversation. The relevant authority can explain what applies to the particular work; a product description alone cannot settle it.

If the home has historic documentation or prior approval records, share those with the people preparing the scope. Keep any written response with your contractor’s drawings so the design, review and installation all refer to the same proposal.

For help discussing a home you are considering, call me at (323) 673-2597.

How do I raise the issue when buying a home?

During the inspection, ask the general inspector to identify windows that are corroded, leaking, stuck or missing functional hardware. Request photos and locations in the report. If concerns appear, arrange a specialist evaluation within the time available under your purchase agreement, and ask what the specialist can and cannot determine without opening or removing material.

Rather than asking for a blanket verdict on every window, request a window-by-window assessment: which appear serviceable, which need maintenance, which need more extensive work and which may be candidates for replacement. Ask whether a leak appears to involve the window, the surrounding wall or an undetermined source. Discuss the findings and your options with your agent before deciding how to proceed.

This week, photograph the windows and check the property in Pasadena’s designated-properties database. If the inspection flags heavy corrosion, get a steel-window specialist’s written assessment before deciding on replacement. Use that assessment to compare the recommended work.

How do windows fit into the rest of an update?

Plan the work together when the window is next to a kitchen or bath renovation. A contractor working around an opening should know whether the sash, trim and surrounding finishes are intended to stay. Protecting those details during other work is easier to discuss before demolition begins than after a feature has been disturbed.

Planning an update? Text me at (323) 673-2597.

If you are planning a sale, see my seller resources.

The same principle applies elsewhere in the house. Review original floor and bathroom tile, consider the routes for central air through plaster interiors, and look at the relationship between windows and an outdoor room in our courtyard and patio maintenance guide. Each decision affects how the house feels as a whole.

Ready to move forward? Let's talk.

Frequently asked questions

Can rusty steel casement windows be repaired?

Often, yes. A specialist can assess how deeply corrosion has affected the metal, remove rust, treat and repaint sound sections, and address the moisture source. Heavy corrosion or missing material calls for a closer assessment.

Does a window that sticks need to be replaced?

Not necessarily. Binding can involve hardware, hinges, alignment or a bent frame. Ask a specialist to identify the cause and explain what adjustment or repair would restore operation.

Can weatherstripping help an original steel window?

Weatherstripping is one option for reducing air leakage around an operable window. The right approach depends on how the sash fits and whether it can still open, close and latch properly.

What should I check before ordering replacement windows?

Ask the local building department about permits and any historic review that may apply to the property and proposed work. Have the installer confirm applicable requirements, measurements, operation and the appearance of the proposed windows before ordering.

Should a buyer ask for a window specialist during inspection?

When the general inspection identifies corrosion, leaks or windows that do not operate properly, a specialist can help clarify the condition and repair options. Ask for a written assessment that distinguishes individual windows and identifies further investigation.

For help weighing the inspection findings and your next steps, call me at (323) 673-2597.

Sources

Justin Borges
Your Agent

Justin Borges

Team Lead, The Borges Real Estate TeamDRE #01940318

13+
Years
$210M+
In Sales
5-Star
Rated

With over 13 years in Southern California real estate, Justin specializes in probate sales, trust properties, and character homes. His expertise in 1031 exchanges and historic preservation has helped hundreds of clients navigate complex real estate transactions.

Trust Sales Specialist

Ready to move forward? Let's talk.

Trust sales are one of my specialties. Whether you are in Pasadena, Glendale, Arcadia, or anywhere in LA County, I am ready to help you navigate this clearly and close with confidence.

Should I Keep or Replace Steel Casement Windows in a Spanish Revival Home? | The Borges Real Estate Team